Release date: July 2013
Genre: Melodic Metalcore / Post Hardcore
Label: Equal Vision (North America), Nuclear Blast (Europe), We Are Unified (Australia)
After listening to this album for half a year I think I am finally ready to review it. This band is an American metalcore band and they sport the unfavorable quality of having clean vocals. Even though that doesn't get you far in the world of core, it is worth remembering that music evolves and leaves us with post-[insert genre]. To all the haters of clean vocals in core.. Remember that this could be a gateway drug to those who don't listen to core and might lead them to increase the strength in the core scene.
Not wasting any time, this album starts with its title track: "Tracing back roots". Not my favorite track on the album but still a decent core track. This is the track that might separate the fans of core and those who want to get into it. 66% of this song gives you the feeling that it is a rather softcore song. Two thirds through you get the post-core feeling. The beat feels core, but clean vocals and keyboards hit you in the face, but in a way you might ask for more.
"Fade away" is number two. Again, it has great guitars which gives you the feeling of a core band. This song is more post-core than the one before. If you had hopes of this album getting harder after the first song, you might want to find something else to listen to. This track is the one you want playing in a club full of drunk core-fans. Having a soft spot for these soft-post-core bands, this is one of the songs that made me have to finish the album. This one keeps your head banging and your lips mouthing the words (if you know them) right after the intro and through the entire song.
"I Survive" is a personal favorite. From the unorthodox start of the song, it makes you question how it will progress. Being a keyboard nerd it is also great to hear the keyboard playing a big part and giving additional feel to the song. This is one of the songs that are not allowed to come up on my Ipod while on the bus because I will start singing along and playing the drums on the back of the head of the person in front of me (sorry to the blonde chick I freaked out the other day). This is a perfect follow up to "Fade away" and is also another track you could play in the company of drunk metal fans and they will dance. The lyrics are interesting and well placed among the music.
Favorite part from the song: "I will keep my head and heart above the waves. My hands are tied but I will make it. I'm not shaken. Even when my mind's exhausted. I survive".
"Ghosts" is next up. Has more core feeling to it than the two songs before it. It has more in common with the title track than the "I survive" and "Fade away". This song has more growling but is heavily keyboard influenced as it plays dreamy keys. Around the 2 minute marker it takes a different turn and makes you understand the dreamy keys that were introduced to you in the beginning. HOWEVER! Just after 2:40 it takes you back to the core that starts about 20 seconds later. This song song is really good, but it doesn't always fit the mood. Being on both ends of the scale, it might take a certain patience to appreciate the song.
If you like NOFX; this song will have some whoa's for you.
"Present, Future, and Past" is next. A song that will kick you in the face after listening to the previous songs. This will make you want to kick things and make strange faces while singing along. It took me awhile to accept this song, but as soon as I did so it was one of the game changers on this album. This is one of the more cory-core songs on the album. However, it will make a turn around the 2 minute mark that will take a different turn. According to the recipe on this album, that mark would be a sign of relaxing and going to "post" from "core". This is not the case. This song takes turns, but you end up where you wanted to. You can listen to this song on repeat and it does not feel weird in any way.
Next up is "Never Let Me Go". Another song based on the soft/post-core genre. It is probably one of the most "pop" songs on the album. Don't get me wrong... This isn't a bad thing. Remember how we want more people to join the metal scene? This is one of those songs you might turn someone to the dark side. A very well written song with some keyboard chapters that fit very well in the background. This is most likely the song that could make it to the radio if some station would hire drunken DJ's. Yes there is an official video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w1nHmQBjfEM (If you can tell me what location they are doing this video in you have 100 rock points coming your way).
"Hope" is next. Heavy keyboard beginning might give you the wrong idea. When they sing "I can run, I can change all the answers" it makes us want to be more drunk than we usually are. A great song that could use some work on. However, they stick with it. This makes it work in the long run. Another song for NOFX fans with some whoa's on it. Not the best song on the album, but still greater than many things that get recognized on the mainstream media.
"Tell Me Now" is a key-core song. Good track but falls in line with what has been before. This is still one of the songs that could be played in the club full of metal fans. The "breakdown" just after the 1:30 mark is a decent one but doesn't give you a fulfilling feeling. This song is a downfall on the album and should maybe have been the first track on a B-side album.
After the next moment comes "A Moment". THE post-core song on this album. Heavily dependent on keyboard on guitar effects. Not saying it is a bad thing! It has great moments and the lesser great moments are still... a great moment. If you do not like clean vocals, do not listen to this album.. Actually, if you don't like clean vocals on a core album I don't think you would have made it this far... So your secret (or not so secret) is safe with us. This is also a song you could play in a club full of core fans in a party mood. Let it rip!!
"I Am Free" fits like a glove after the previous track. Post-corey madness gives you a feeling of partying. If you haven't felt like extreme-dancing in your room before this track, you should now (please don't do it in public. It isn't cool. We promise).
Favorite part: "I keep my mind. Always open ended".
Final track: "Through the Darkest Dark and Brightest Bright". Starts by core-ing you in the cornhole. But is also heavily keyboard dependent and a lot of clean vocals. Not the greatest song to end the album, but it is a "song to remember". This one has some overwhelming prog-rock feeling to it in some chapters and makes you think this was the last song to be recorded and the keyboard player thought: "I haven't been shining enough". Feels like there is a song that should follow this one and it kind of leaves you hanging.
Summary: Some bands that play core music of this altitude give you the feeling that they are kidding. We Came As Romans do not do that. They might look like pretty boys that belong in the club, but they will probably kick your ass if you start any s**t with them. Adding keyboards and harmonies to post-core is a great way to get more people to join the metal scene. The album is mastered in a pop-kind of way but it fits more than any other way. John Feldman produced the album and probably got things from it we wouldn't have heard without him. Feldman has an ear for this kind of music ("The Used", "Atreyu", "Panic at the Disco"..) and it didn't fail him this time. This song is very well produced. If you like acoustic versions of metal songs I recommend you "youtube" them.
Listen if you like: Eskimo Callboy, Of Mice & Men, A Day To Remember, Asking Alexandria and Attack Attack!